Contributors
813.229.4304
407.244.8235
813.229.4301
202.965.8181
813.229.4362
305.347.6823
305.347.6990
860.392.5038
305.539.7309
561.650.0354
561.822.2972
561.650.8014
305.539.7230
202.295.6525
212.380.9612
305.539.7330
860.392.5053
202.965.8129
202.965.8126
202.965.8107
   
  
  
   
(Click to edit)


Sixth Circuit Vacates Class Certification Order Due To State Court Settlement

April 11, 2012 11:34 AM | Posted by Kathryn H. Christian | Print this page
In Gooch v. Life Investors Insurance Company of America, Nos. 10–5003, 10–5723, 2012 WL 410926 (6th Cir. Feb. 10, 2012), the Sixth Circuit noted that the district court improperly applied the "clearly wrong" standard in deciding class certification by assuming the class representative's allegations to be true and resolving all doubts “in the plaintiff's favor” while conducting what it called “[a] limited factual inquiry into the class allegations, including the deposition of the named plaintiff.” The court noted this did not comply with the “rigorous analysis” standard, but concluded the error was harmless because the court based its decision on affidavits it deemed sufficient, probed behind the pleadings, and considered all relevant documents in evidence. The court ultimately vacated the class certification order because a state court settlement precluded the claims of most class members

Related Information

Related Services